Secession Era Editorials Project
An Atrocious Speech and a Disgraceful Assault.
Detroit, Michigan, Free Press [Democratic]
(23 May 1856)
Senator Sumner, of Massachusetts, delivered an atrocious speech the other
day in the Senate.
It was fitly characterized by Gen. Cass as the most un-American
and unpatriotic speech he ever heard on the floor of the Senate; by
Mr. Douglas as filled with libels and insults, gross and vulgar,
which their author had conned over and written with cool and deliberate
malignity, and repeated before the looking-glass, night after night, in order to find the appropriate grace with which to spit them at
men who differ from him, and by Mr. Mason, as language which
Senators were compelled to listen to in that chamber, because the constitution
permitted its utterance there, but which no gentleman would lend an ear to
It was an atrocious speech.
But its atrocity did not warrant the personal assault upon him by a South
Carolina member of the House of Representatives.
-- That was a cowardly assault -- the manner of it as well as the spirit by
which it was dictated.
-- We do not know what conduct, public or private, would justify such an
assault -- the coming stealthily upon an unarmed man, in a sitting posture, and
prostrating him at a single blow of a bludgeon.
We trust that, on one of these occasions, the assailing party will become
the assailed, and that a lesson will be taught profitable to all combatants of
the character of Mr. Preston S. Brooks.
This document was produced as part of a document analysis project
by Lloyd Benson, Department of History, Furman University.
(Proofing info: Transcribed and reverse-order proofed by Lloyd Benson.)
This electronic version may not be copied, or linked to, or otherwise used for commercial purposes, (including textbook or publication-related websites)
without prior written permission. The views expressed in this
document are for educational, historical, and scholarly use only,
and are not intended to represent the views of the project contributors or